ENVIRONMENTAL PRESSURE OF MAJOR TOURISM INFRASTRUCTURES: GOLF COURSES

    Descrizione 1
    Update date
    Authors

    Giovanni Finocchiaro, Daria Gorozhankina, Silvia Iaccarino

    Abstract
    Immagine
    Abstract

    Among the infrastructures for tourism activities, golf courses have a strong impact on the surrounding environment. The consumption of resources (e.g., water extraction, land occupation, etc.) and the pollution produced, for example, by the use of pesticides, are the main concerns. In response, the Italian golf movement is increasingly directing its development toward an environmentally friendly approach through certifications (GEO) or environmental recognitions. In 2022, the total number of golf courses was 367.

    Description

    Tourism activity infrastructures, particularly golf courses, have a strong impact on the surrounding environment. The consumption of resources (e.g., water extraction, land occupation, etc.) and the pollution produced, for example, by the use of pesticides, are among the major concerns. In recent years, at the European level, the popularity of golf tourism has increased, and consequently, the number of golf courses has grown.

    Golf courses require an enormous amount of water every day and, as with other causes of excessive extraction, this can lead to a water deficit. Golf resorts are increasingly located in protected areas or in regions where resources are limited, further exacerbating the generated pressure.

    The indicator records the number of Italian golf clubs and some environmental characteristics of interest, including those that have obtained environmental certifications.

    Purpose

    To quantify golf tourism and the related facilities in order to monitor their potential impact on the surrounding environment.

    Policy relevance and utility for users
    It is of national scope or it is applicable to environmental issues at the regional level but of national relevance.
    It is simple and easy to interpret.
    It provides a basis for international comparisons.
    Analytical soundness
    Be based on international standards and international consensus about its validity;
    Temporal comparability
    Spatial comparability
    Measurability (data)
    Updated at regular intervals in accordance with reliable procedures
    Readily available or made available at a reasonable cost/benefit ratio
    An “adequate” spatial coverage
    Main regulatory references and objectives

    The indicator has no direct references to specific regulatory elements, nor are there any regulatory obligations to comply with. However, it falls within the context of European and national policies on sustainable tourism, European regulations related to marine-coastal ecosystems (e.g., Marine Strategy Framework Directive and/or Habitats Directive), and national and/or local planning regulations.

    DPSIR
    Pressure
    Impact
    Indicator type
    Descriptive (A)
    References

    -Gössling, S., Peeters, P., Hall, C.M, Ceron, J.P., Dubois, G., Lehmann, L.V. & Scott, D. (2012): Tourism and water use: Supply, demand, and security. An international review. Tourism Management 33 (1): 1-15.
    -Tanner, R.A. & Gange, A.C. (2005): Effects of golf courses on local biodiversity. Landscape and Urban Planning 71 (2-4): 137-146)
    -Regione Puglia - POR 2000-2006 "GOLF e AMBIENTE - Impatti ambientali e indicazioni per la sostenibilità"

    Further actions

    Lack of precise knowledge of the surface area of each golf club.

    Frequenza di rilevazione dei dati
    Annuale
    Fonte dei dati
    Federgolf
    Data availabilty

    http://www.federgolf.it/

    Spatial coverage

    National, Regional

    Time coverage

    September 2023

    Processing methodology

    The indicator reports: The number of golf clubs distributed by region; The number of clubs with GEO environmental certification; The number of clubs "Impegnati nel verde"; The number of courses using reclaimed water; the number of courses built on former degraded areas; The number of courses using clean energy; The ratio between the estimated surface area of golf clubs in each region and the total area of that region

    Update frequency
    Year
    Qualità dell'informazione

    Despite the fact that the information source for Italy does not come from official statistics but from administrative data (sports federation), the accuracy of the indicator can be considered acceptable. Additionally, the uniqueness of the data source ensures a good level of comparability over time and space.

    State
    Medium
    Trend
    Undefinable
    State assessment/description

    The number of golf facilities in Italy reached 367 in 2022. The number of facilities adhering to "green" initiatives has increased. From an environmental perspective, this allows us to classify the status as "medium", both in terms of lower infrastructure impact and greater environmental awareness.

    Trend assessment/description

    It is not yet possible to identify a trend; however, the Italian golf movement is striving to develop while taking environmental conservation into account. This is demonstrated by the many "green" initiatives and certifications activated in the sector.

    Comments

    At the global level, the "cradle of golf" is represented by English-speaking and Northern European countries, thanks to their long tradition and favorable climatic conditions, particularly high rainfall. In Mediterranean countries, however, the low rainfall and high risk of desertification have hindered expansion at the same rate, as the construction and maintenance of golf courses are much more expensive, compromising their economic and environmental sustainability.

    The growth of golf in Italy, in terms of facilities, has seen almost exponential increases. Those with GEO certification represent 4.4% of the total (Table 1). The Italian golf movement, with its facilities, is mostly concentrated in Northern Italy, especially in the Po Valley, where about 53% of golf structures are located in Lombardy, Piedmont, Veneto, and Emilia-Romagna (Figure 1). In Central Italy, golf facilities are more widely distributed in Tuscany and Lazio, while about 12% are in the South and the Islands.

    The number of golf courses located in protected areas has also been calculated (Table 4). Among the registered golf courses, about 80% are in a Regional Park.

    The construction of a golf course increases land use. For example, a medium-sized 18-hole golf course occupies approximately 60 hectares, of which about 50% requires medium to high-intensity maintenance, a disadvantageous feature for protected areas.

    Other environmental concerns include:

    • The removal of existing vegetation cover
    • Excessive chemical treatment of the soil
    • Significant water demand, which can contribute to desertification or soil degradation
    • The salinization of groundwater, especially in coastal areas, where new wells are often indiscriminately drilled to irrigate golf courses, increasing the risk of groundwater salinization and threatening drinking and agricultural water sources

    From a biodiversity perspective, the construction of a golf course inevitably modifies existing vegetation and habitats, negatively impacting flora, fauna, ecological chains, and the landscape.

    Despite these environmental concerns, the Italian and international golf movement is increasingly steering its growth toward an "eco-friendly" approach.

    • Of the 367 Italian golf clubs, 16 have obtained GEO environmental certification (Table 1). The GEO certification process, published on www.golfenvironment.org, ensures transparency and objectivity in certification while helping clubs analyze their environmental policies and identify areas for improvement.
    • 92 clubs (25%) have received the "Impegnati nel verde" (INV) recognition, an initiative by the Italian Golf Federation that promotes the eco-sustainable development of golf, raising awareness among clubs and players and guiding them toward GEO certification.

    Additionally, sustainability efforts include:

    • 9 courses using reclaimed water
    • 21 courses using renewable energy (Table 2)
    • 22 golf courses built on reclaimed degraded areas, mainly former landfills or gravel quarries (Table 3)

    These initiatives demonstrate that the Italian golf movement is working towards a more sustainable approach, balancing sport and environmental responsibility.

    Data
    Headline

    Table 1: “Eco-certified” golf clubs (30/09/2023)

    Data source

    ISPRA processing based on Federgolf data

    Data legend

    Certifications are updated to October 2020

    Headline

    Table 2: “Eco-friendly” golf courses

    Data source

    ISPRA processing based on Federgolf data

    Data legend

    Updated as of September 2020

    Headline

    Table 3: Golf courses developed on former degraded areas

    Data source

    ISPRA processing based on Federgolf data

    Data legend

    Updated as of February 2019

    Headline

    Table 4: Golf clubs located within protected areas

    Data source

    ISPRA processing based on Federgolf data

    Data legend

    Updated as of January 2021

    Thumbnail
    Headline

    Figure 1: Number of golf clubs in Italy (2022)

    Data source

    ISPRA processing based on Federgolf data

    Headline

    dati per figura 1 numero golf club

    English