EXCEEDANCES OF REGULATORY REFERENCE VALUES FOR ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS GENERATED BY RADIOCOMMUNICATION INSTALLATIONS, REMEDIATION ACTIONS

Update date
Authors

Gabriele Bellabarba, Maria Logorelli

Abstract

For each autonomous region/province, the number of exceedances of the regulatory reference values ​​is considered, distinguished by radio and television systems (RTV) and base transceiver stations (BTS), and the number of remediations, being verified by ARPA/APPA, in progress (for administrative actions), concluded for ARPA/APPA verification and concluded for administrative actions. Exceedance concerns situations in which levels above the exposure limit or the warning value or both are measured. From the data provided for the period 1999 - September 2025 it appears that the cases of exceeding the legal limits regarding RTV systems (605) are 4.4 times higher than those relating to BTS systems (138). The renovations completed for the RTV and BTS plants are equal to 76.5% and 74.7% of the total, respectively. For the regions whose data is updated for both types of systems and comparable, it can be noted that, in the two reference time periods 1999-September 2024 and 1999-September 2025, the cases of exceeding the legal limits for RTVs and BTSs increased slightly, respectively, by 0.3% (going from 603 to 605) and by 0.7% (going from 137 y 138).

Description

For each autonomous region/province, the number of exceedances of the regulatory reference values ​​are reported, broken down by radio and television systems (RTV) and base transceiver stations (BTS), and the number of cases of exceedance for which the remediations required by law are scheduled, under verification by ARPA/APPA, in progress (due to administrative actions), concluded due to ARPA/APPA verification and concluded due to administrative actions. Exceeding concerns situations in which levels higher than the exposure limit or the warning value or both are measured, reporting the cumulative value over the reference time frame. 

Purpose

Quantify the non-compliance situations detected by the control activity, carried out by the ARPA/APPA, on the radio frequency (RF) sources present in the territory (radio television systems (RTV) and base transceiver stations (BTS)) and the status of the remediation.

Policy relevance and utility for users
It is of national scope or applicable to environmental issues at the regional level but of national significance.
It is able to describe the trend without necessarily providing an evaluation of it.
It is simple and easy to interpret.
It provides a representative overview of environmental conditions, environmental pressures, and societal responses.
Analytical soundness
Temporal comparability
Spatial comparability
Measurability (data)
Readily available or made available at a reasonable cost/benefit ratio
An “adequate” spatial coverage
An “appropriate” temporal coverage
Main regulatory references and objectives

Ministerial Decree 381/1998 sets exposure limits, to be respected in any situation, and precautionary values, to be respected in places where a stay of more than 4 hours is expected. These limit values ​​confirmed by the Prime Ministerial Decree 08/07/03 and subsequent amendments also introduce a further threshold of attention defined as "quality objective", in implementation of Law 36/2001. These regulatory provisions provide that, where exceedances occur, remediation actions must be implemented at the expense of the owners of the plants.

DPSIR
State
Response
Indicator type
Descriptive (A)
References

ISPRA - Environmental data yearbook, various years

ISPRA/MASE/SNPA, Thematic reports 

Limitations

The information processed is affected by some problems such as lack of consolidated data collection tools at a local level, lack of human and financial resources dedicated to this data collection activity, no obligation on the part of the competent authority (Municipality or Province) to inform ARPA/APPA of the state of the art of the remediation action from the latter request following the situation of non-compliance of a given plant. It should be highlighted that the information regarding the status of the recovery actions corresponds to the current state of knowledge of the ARPA/APPA agency system.

Further actions

Synergistic actions by the subjects involved in trying to support the flow of information with suitable regulatory tools and with activities aimed at analyzing the critical issues mentioned above in order to shed light on the problems and propose solutions to give greater uniformity and completeness to the data at a national level.

Data source

Electromagnetic Fields Observatory

Data collection frequency
Real time
Spatial coverage

17/20

Time coverage

1999-September 2025

Processing methodology

Calculation of the number of exceedances of the regulatory reference values ​​and the number of cases of exceedance for which there are planned remediation actions, being verified by ARPA/APPA, in progress (for administrative actions), concluded due to ARPA/APPA verification, concluded due to administrative actions, no action taken. Exceedance concerns situations in which levels above the exposure limit or the warning value or both are measured. In the calculation, the regions that provided updated and complete data are considered.

Update frequency
Year
Data quality

The indicator presents information that covers a good part of the national territory. The time series that can be constructed with the information available refers to a period exceeding five years. The indicator is easily interpretable and has good spatial and temporal comparability. 

Status
Good
Trend
Steady
State assessment/description

According to what is reported in Tables 1 and 2 relating to the regions for which the data was updated in September 2025 for both types of source (Piedmont, Valle d'Aosta, Lombardy, Trentino-Alto Adige, Veneto, Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Liguria, Emilia-Romagna, Tuscany, Umbria, Lazio, Abruzzo, Molise, Campania, Puglia, Basilicata and Calabria) it is noted that the cases of exceeding the legal limits regarding RTV systems (605) are 4.4 times higher than those relating to BTS systems (138). The renovations completed for the RTV and BTS plants are equal to 76.5% and 74.7% of the total respectively (Figure 1).

Trend assessment/description

For the autonomous regions/provinces (Piedmont, Valle d'Aosta, Lombardy, Autonomous Province of Trento, Veneto, Friuli Venezia Giulia, Liguria, Emilia-Romagna, Tuscany, Umbria, Lazio, Campania, Puglia, Basilicata and Calabria) whose data is updated for both types of system and comparable for the period in question, the cases of exceeding the legal limits for RTVs and BTSs have increased slightly in the two reference periods, 1999-September 2024 and 1999-September 2025, respectively, by 0.3% (going from 603 to 605) and 0.7% (going from 137 to 138) (Table 3 and 4).

Comments

The available data highlights that although there are many environmental critical issues linked to the presence of these electromagnetic sources in the urban area, the situations of non-compliance which indicate that the limits imposed by current legislation have been exceeded in the face of intense control activity by the territorially competent bodies do not undergo significant increases. This indicates a situation of substantial balance between the need for technological development on the part of the managers of these plants and the protection of the environment and the population, which are guaranteed through valid regulatory, information and technological tools. 

Data
Data
Headline

Table 1: Number of exceedances detected and remediation status for radiotelevision (RTV) installations (1999–September 2025).

Data source

ISPRA processing based on ARPA/APPA data (EMF Observatory).

Data legend

a Data not updated;
b Region/Autonomous Province that provided complete and up-to-date data and was therefore included in the calculation of the overall national total.

Headline

Table 2: Number of exceedances detected and remediation status for base transceiver stations (BTS) (1999–September 2025).

Data source

ISPRA processing based on ARPA/APPA data (EMF Observatory).

Data legend

a Data not updated;
b Region/Autonomous Province that provided complete and up-to-date data and was therefore included in the calculation of the overall national total.

Headline

Table 3: Number of exceedances detected and remediation status for radiotelevision (RTV) installations in the two time periods 1999–September 2025 and 1999–September 2024.

Data source

ISPRA processing based on ARPA/APPA data (EMF Observatory).

Data legend

a Data not updated;
b Region/Autonomous Province that provided complete and up-to-date data and was therefore included in the calculation of the overall national total.

Headline

Table 4: Number of exceedances detected and remediation status for base transceiver stations (BTS) in the two time periods 1999–September 2025 and 1999–September 2024.

Data source

ISPRA processing based on ARPA/APPA data (EMF Observatory).

Data legend

a Data not updated;
b Region/Autonomous Province that provided complete and up-to-date data and was therefore included in the calculation of the overall national total.
 

Thumbnail
Headline

Figure 1: Status of remediation actions at sites where at least one exceedance due to RTV and BTS installations was detected (1999–September 2025).

Data source

ISPRA processing based on ARPA/APPA data (EMF Observatory).

Note

Only the regions for which updated and complete data are available for the 1999–September 2025 time period were considered.